Hot Teachers Who Sexually Assaulted Their Underage Students

Fatima Grupico

Fatima Grupico, 24, a history teacher at a now-defunct Catholic high school in central New Jersey is accused of repeatedly having sex with a 17-year-old male student. 

The Middlesex County prosecutor has charged Fatima Grupico, of Linden, with sexual assault and child endangerment.

Grupico is accused of having sex with the boy at Cardinal McCarrick High School in South Amboy on several occasions.

Megan Mahoney

Born in 1993, was a gym teacher at Moore Catholic High School in Staten Island. She offered to “coach” a male student (then 16 years old) in basketball, but what she really meant was something else. They then began an affair, continuing from October 2014, to January 2014.

Mahoney, in addition to teaching gym, was the schools assistant athletic director and assistant girls basketball coach at the time.

Police claim that she and the student had sex at least twice and week. The affair came to light when Mahoney and the student were caught engaging in a sexual act at a local pizza parlor and the student involved also bragged about the relationship to his friends.

Mahoney resigned from her job and the student was expelled in January 2014, when officials informed the school of the affair. In October 2014, Mahoney was charged with 30 counts of statutory rape and and four counts of criminal sexual acts.

Heather Daughdrill

28 year old Heather Daughdrill had sex with a young, 13 year old boy after meeting him at a summer Bible camp. “The investigation revealed Daughdrill would engage in inappropriate sexual contact with the boy after picking him up from school without the parents’ knowledge,” the press release explains. Lewd text messages were found between her and the boy.  She faces criminal charges such as sexual battery, carnal knowledge of a juvenile, kidnapping, indecent behavior with a juvenile and contributing to delinquency

Shelley Dufresne & Rachel Respess

Two Louisiana High School teachers have been arrested after allegedly having a threesome with a student who was 16 at the time.

Shelley Dufresne (right), 33, was charged with carnal knowledge of a juvenile and contributing to the delinquency of a juvenile. Fellow English teacher Rachel Respess(left), 23, faces the same charges.

Dufresne is married with three children and has been teaching at DHS for 10 years. Respess graduated from Destrehan in 2008 and has been teaching at the school for two years.

The student is 17 years old now, but was 16 at the time the alleged crime took place. The student bragged to classmates about having sex with two teachers and also claimed to have some sessions captured on video, which resulted in a St. Charles Parish Sheriff’s Office investigation.

Melody Lippert & Michelle Ghirelli

Michelle Ghirelli, a 30-year-old teacher at a West Covina, CA high school, has been arrested for participating in sexual acts with students while another teacher, 38-year-old Melody Lippert, was present. In two separate encounters – one with Lippert, one without – Ghirelli organized parties and sleepovers at a San Clemente beach in Southern California. Students took to Twitter to express their lack of surprise that the flirty teacher was finally caught engaging in inappropriate behavior with students.

Amber Jennings

Amber Jennings, 30, a Massachusetts teacher, emailed nude photos of herself (and one video) to a 16-year-old male student. She served two years probation.

Christina Oliver

Oliver was a 24-year-old teacher from California who had sex with a 16-year-old male student. He was a student in her sophomore English class and supposedly had sex with him multiple times before his father called the cops. Oliver pleaded guilty to four counts of having sex with a minor, did 150 days in county jail, and got 5 years probation

Kayla Mooney

Police say what started as an invitation from a 17-year old student to his high school physics teacher to attend a concert turned into a relationship that culminated with the teacher having sex with the student and buying him alcohol.

Kayla Mooney, 24, who is on paid leave from Danbury High School, turned herself in following a seven-week investigation. The first-year science teacher was charged with felony second-degree sexual assault and the misdemeanor alcohol charge.

Sarah Jones

This infamous ex-Bengals cheerleader, 27, who was working as a teacher at an Ohio school made every teenager’s dream come true after banging a 17-year-old student.  She ended up getting arrested after hooking up with him on several occasions and fought in court.  She is now in a relationship with the student, after divorcing her husband, and is set to have her own television show. America!

Hope Jacoby

Arrested on the final day of school, Hope Jacoby was taken in for having a sexual relationship with a boy between 14 and 17 years old. This was confirmed once a picture of her was found on the male student’s cell phone. The 23 year old physical trainer at Tustin High School went free on bail, but was tried for oral copulation with a minor and unlawful sex with a minor.

Lindsay Massaro

Sussex County elementary school teacher Lindsay Massaro, 26, taught 8th grade students.  She was accused of having sex with a 15 year old boy in her car and then in her bedroom after the victim’s father reported it to the authorities.  The relationship was consensual. She faces parole supervision for life.

Lisa Glide

Lisa Glide was sentenced to 5 years probation and faced up to a year in prison.  She had sexual intercourse with a 17 and a half year old boy twice. The boy said the following:

“I feel the entire case was blown far out of proportion and reason,” the victim wrote once he was a college sophomore. “I was the initiator of the contact, not Lisa Glide. I was clearly not a young child and Lisa Glide was not a sexual predator.”

Carrie McCandless

Carrie McCandless taught cheerleading at Brighton Charter High School in Colorado. She was accused of having sexual relations with a 17 year old male student during an sleepover school camping trip.  She provided the kids with alcohol and “did everything except having sex” with a male student while another male student slept nearby. She was sentenced to 45 days in jail.

Amy McElhenney

25 year old Spanish teacher and former Miss Texas contestant Amy McElhenney was accused of having sex with an 18 year old male student.  The age of consent in Texas is 18, but there’s a law forbidding teachers from having sexual relationships with students regardless of their age. The grand jury refused to find her guilty of an improper relationship with a student since the text messages colored their relationship as endearing and flirtatious, but she did lose her teacher credentials.

Michelle Preston

Michelle Preston, 27, of Shawnee Mission West High School, Kansas, was charged with three counts of having unlawful sexual relations between September and December 2010. She had sex with three students at her school aged 16 and 17. Naked photos of Preston – who taught psychology and geography as well as freshman cheerleading – were said to have been circulated by the students after the details of the affairs emerged.

Pamela Rogers Turner

Pamela Rogers Turner was 27 and an elementary school teacher/coach when she was arrested in February 2005 for having an ongoing relationship with a 13-year-old student. In August of 2005, she pleaded no contest to charges of sexual battery by an authority figure and was sentenced to 9 months in prison, as part of an 8 year suspended sentence for statutory rape.

In April 2006, she was arrested for turning around and doing it again! Turner was sentenced to serve the remaining seven years of her sentence in state prison, along with two more years after she pleaded guilty to sending the student naked pictures of herself which never resurfaced.

Amy Northcutt

Amy Northcutt and her husband, Justin Northcutt, were arrested for sending lewd text messages to a 16-year old female student and then arranging to have group sex with her.